Glossary

Lazarus Theory of Emotion: Appraisal Model Explained

Updated Published 4 min read

What is Lazarus’s theory of emotion?

Richard S. Lazarus’s cognitive appraisal theory explains emotion in terms of how a person evaluates a situation’s significance for their goals and well-being. The same event can have different emotional meanings for different people.

In Lazarus's theory, appraisal of an event's significance plays a central role in producing the emotional response. Appraisal can be rapid and automatic; it does not require deliberate reflection.

Lazarus called his later formulation a cognitive-motivational-relational theory (Lazarus, 1991). Introductory textbooks such as Psychology 2e call it the cognitive-mediational theory, because the appraisal mediates between the event and the emotional response.

Primary and secondary appraisal

Primary appraisal concerns what is at stake; secondary appraisal concerns coping possibilities and expectations about what can be done. These labels describe aspects of evaluation, not a rigid sequence of two conscious steps. Appraisal and reappraisal can change as a situation develops.

Lazarus (1991) described six appraisal judgments, three primary and three secondary.

Primary appraisal, about what is at stake:

  • Goal relevance: does this matter to me? Without a stake, there is no potential for an emotion.
  • Goal congruence or incongruence: does it help or harm what I want? Harm or threat leads to a negative emotion; benefit leads to a positive one.
  • Type of ego-involvement: which kind of goal is at stake, for example one's ego identity, a moral value or living up to an ego ideal?

Secondary appraisal, about the options and prospects for coping:

  • Blame or credit: who is responsible for what happened, oneself or someone else?
  • Coping potential: can I influence the situation for the better?
  • Future expectations: are things likely to work out or get worse?

In “Cognition and Motivation in Emotion” (1991), Lazarus discusses both deliberate and automatic forms of appraisal. His account should not be reduced to the claim that people always consciously interpret an event before feeling anything.

Core relational themes

Lazarus summarized the appraisal pattern behind each emotion as a core relational theme: a short statement of what the situation means for the person. Some examples, in his words (Lazarus, 2000, adapted from Emotion and Adaptation, 1991):

EmotionCore relational theme
AngerA demeaning offense against me and mine
AnxietyFacing uncertain, existential threat
FrightAn immediate, concrete, and overwhelming physical danger
GuiltHaving transgressed a moral imperative
ShameFailing to live up to an ego-ideal
SadnessHaving experienced an irrevocable loss
ReliefA distressing goal-incongruent condition that has changed for the better or gone away
HopeFearing the worst but yearning for better, and believing the improvement is possible

Worked example: the same presentation, different emotions

A difficult presentation might be evaluated as a threat or as a manageable challenge, depending on what matters to the speaker and their perceived coping resources. A speaker who sees a chance to explain useful work may respond differently from one who sees a public test they cannot handle.

Lazarus and other classic theories of emotion

The table summarizes the main claim of four classic theories. Each is a theoretical account, not a settled description of every emotion.

TheoryMain claim
James-LangePerceiving an event produces bodily changes, and feeling those changes constitutes the emotion.
Cannon-BardBrain processes can produce the emotional experience and the bodily response together.
Schachter-Singer (two-factor)An emotional state depends on physiological arousal together with a cognition that explains the arousal.
Lazarus (cognitive appraisal)An emotion depends on how a person appraises what an event means for their goals and well-being.

The contrast with Schachter and Singer (1962) is the sharpest. In their account, a cognitive label explains arousal that is already present. In Lazarus's account, the appraisal of meaning comes before the emotional response and shapes it.

What the evidence shows

In an early experiment, Speisman, Lazarus, Mordkoff and Davison (1964) showed a film of an adolescent initiation rite either silently or with one of three soundtracks. A soundtrack that pointed up the threatening aspects increased skin conductance, a physiological measure of stress. Soundtracks that offered a denying or a detached, intellectualized account reduced it, although denial was less effective for the student participants. The images were the same in every condition.

Smith and Ellsworth (1985) asked 16 students to recall experiences of 15 emotions and rate how they had appraised each situation. Six appraisal dimensions, including pleasantness, certainty, responsibility and control, differed systematically across the emotions. From the appraisal ratings alone, the emotion was identified correctly more than 40% of the time.

Smith and Ellsworth's study relied on participants recalling past experiences. It found associations between reported appraisals and emotions, but did not establish whether the appraisals caused the emotions. The role of cognition also remains disputed: Robert Zajonc argued that some emotions can occur before, or separately from, cognitive interpretation (see Psychology 2e).

Appraisal, coping, and emotion regulation

Problem-focused coping addresses the situation; emotion-focused coping addresses the emotional response. Preparing the presentation more thoroughly and managing distress about it are different responses to the same event. Reappraisal means evaluating the situation again as information or circumstances change. None of these labels shows that reinterpretation alone will solve a real obstacle.

The broader account appears in Emotion and Adaptation (1991). A theoretical explanation of emotion does not by itself establish the effectiveness of a particular treatment or regulation technique.

Sources and further reading